Women make up the majority of nonprofit staff at every level. Yet the gender pay gap persists in senior leadership. According to the 2026 CharityVillage Canadian Nonprofit Sector Salary and Benefits Report, men in Chief Executive roles earned approximately 20% more on average than women in comparable roles. At other management levels, the reported gap ranged from approximately 4% to 13%.
This is not only an equity issue. It is also a financial sustainability issue. When boards set budgets that rely on leaders to absorb extra work, delay fair compensation, or fill finance, human resources and operations gaps themselves, the organization may appear to be managing. In reality, it may be depending on capacity that cannot last.
The practical question for a board is not whether a leader is committed to the mission. It is whether the organization has budgeted honestly for the people, skills and systems required to deliver that mission well.
What Does the 2026 Canadian Nonprofit Compensation Data Show?
The 2026 CharityVillage Canadian Nonprofit Sector Salary and Benefits Report included 924 completed surveys representing 11,182 employees across six staff levels. It found that women remain the majority of nonprofit staff across all levels. However, men in Chief Executive roles earned approximately 20% more on average than women in the same leadership level. At other management levels, the gap ranged from approximately 4% to 13%.
The report also shows why a single-sector average isn't enough for a fair compensation conversation. Pay differs by region, organization size, focus area and role. Chief Executives at organizations with annual revenue over $5 million earned more than twice as much as those at organizations with revenue under $500,000. Boards therefore need comparable data that reflects their organization’s size, region and responsibilities, rather than relying only on the previous year’s budget.
CharityVillage’s report does not establish why the gender pay gap exists in every organization. It does establish that boards and leaders have a credible reason to examine their own compensation practices, especially at senior levels.
The Issue Behind the Pay Gap: The Real Cost of Leadership
Compensation decisions are often difficult in mission-driven organizations. Funding can be restricted. A board may feel accountable to donors, funders, and the community to limit administrative costs. Leaders may hesitate to ask for a salary review when their teams also need raises or when program needs are urgent.
Those pressures are real. However, a budget doesn't become sustainable just because it balances on paper.
At Enkel’s panel discussion, Women and the Hidden Crisis in Canada’s Nonprofit Sector, women leaders described a recurring reality: an Executive Director may be leading programs and fundraising while also serving as finance, human resources and technology lead. The work may require long hours, deferred improvements, and personal sacrifice. But financial statements don’t always reflect those costs.
This is sometimes called the accidental CFO problem. An Executive Director becomes the person who must review reports, answer Payroll questions, manage vendor payments, prepare for the audit, and explain financial results to the board because no defined finance structure is in place. The organization may survive this way for a period, but that doesn't mean the model is working.
Five Lessons From Women Leading Canadian Nonprofits
The panel conversation adds useful context to the compensation data. These are not national findings on their own. They are practical leadership lessons boards can test against their own organization's reality.
1. An Executive Director cannot carry every operational function indefinitely
When one person becomes the default owner of finance, people operations, technology and program delivery, decision-making slows and organizational risk increases. The concern is not that an Executive Director should understand none of these areas. A strong leader should understand the signals and know which questions to ask.
The concern is that no one else has clear responsibility for the work.
A more sustainable model defines the roles around the Executive Director. Routine records, payroll, and payables need a dependable process. Monthly reports need someone who can explain what changed. Senior financial oversight should be available when the organization faces material risks, funding decisions or growth plans.
For organizations that need more oversight than day-to-day bookkeeping but don't need a full-time finance leader, a fractional Controller can help establish a regular close, clearer reporting, and stronger financial ownership.
2. A balanced budget can still hide an unsustainable workload
A program budget may show enough funding to deliver the work. Yet it may not show unpaid overtime, postponed salary adjustments, leaders covering vacant roles or the time spent fixing finance processes that should already be supported.
Boards should ask a direct question during budget planning: What does it actually cost to deliver this work with healthy staffing, fair compensation and the right operational support?
This does not mean that every organization can solve every funding gap immediately. It means the board should see the gap clearly. A budget that relies on people repeatedly doing more with less is not simply efficient. It shifts financial pressure onto the people doing the work.
Capacity planning should sit alongside revenue and expense planning. It should include the roles required, the cost of vacancies, expected overtime, external support requirements and the delivery risks if funding does not arrive as planned.
3. Scarcity should not become the organization’s permanent operating model
Resourcefulness is a strength in the nonprofit sector. It can lead to creative partnerships, strong community relationships and practical solutions. But constantly expecting to make do with less can also normalize decisions that weaken the organization over time.
When an organization cannot pay a leader fairly, maintain its finance process or fund the staffing needed for a program, the board needs to address the underlying operating model. This may include changing the scope of delivery, building a stronger unrestricted revenue plan, setting clearer funding conditions or reviewing the program mix.
The answer is not always to raise more money quickly. It may be to make a more deliberate decision about what the organization can sustain. Nonprofit financial planning can help boards make those trade-offs visible through a realistic budget, cash forecast and predefined decision triggers.
4. Donor concerns should not prevent a fair compensation conversation
Some nonprofit leaders worry that donors or the public may misunderstand an appropriate salary. That concern can make compensation discussions difficult, especially when the organization is already under financial pressure.
Boards should not respond by avoiding the question. They should be prepared to explain the organization’s approach: compensation is reviewed using relevant market data, approved through an appropriate governance process and connected to the responsibilities required to deliver the mission.
A fair compensation decision is not an argument for unchecked spending. It is an argument for a transparent, evidence-based process. The board should consider the full role, the organization’s size and complexity, regional labour conditions, benefits, internal equity and the cost of replacing key leadership.
5. Funding volatility makes clear reporting and cash planning more important
Panel participants also described how quickly an organization’s position can change when a major funder delays or reduces funding. In these moments, boards need more than an annual budget. They need a current view of cash, committed costs, restricted funds and the choices available.
A rolling cash forecast helps leadership see whether it can meet payroll, rent, vendor payments, and program commitments under different conditions. It also helps the board decide early whether to slow hiring, defer spending, use reserves, adjust delivery or begin funding conversations.
Cash flow planning for nonprofits is not about predicting every outcome perfectly. It gives leaders time to respond before a funding change becomes an immediate cash crisis.
What Can Nonprofit Boards Do to Address Fair Compensation?
The responsibility for fair compensation shouldn't sit only with the underpaid employee. The board has a governance role in setting a compensation process that is consistent, documented and connected to the organization’s financial reality.
Use relevant compensation benchmarks
Review comparable compensation by role, organization size, geography and focus area. The CharityVillage report provides data across regions, staff levels and organization types. A board should not automatically copy an average. It should use credible data to inform a documented decision.
Review total compensation, not salary alone
Base salary matters, but so do benefits, retirement support, paid leave, flexibility, professional development and the scope of the role. If an Executive Director is expected to carry responsibilities beyond their position, the board should assess whether the role itself needs to change, not simply whether a salary adjustment is due.
Create a regular review rhythm
Do not wait for a resignation risk or a crisis. Set a defined annual or periodic compensation review process. Document the evidence considered, the decision made and the next review date. This gives the Executive Director a fair process without requiring them to make the case alone each time.
Build the full cost of delivery into the budget
The board should understand what it costs to deliver programs with appropriate staffing and operational support. If the organization is bridging gaps with unpaid labour, deferred salaries or leaders performing multiple unresourced roles, that should be visible in the planning discussion.
Connect compensation to financial reporting and capacity planning
A board cannot govern compensation well without current financial information. The regular board package should include budget-to-actual results, a cash forecast, staffing or capacity changes, significant risks and the decisions required next. Clear financial reporting for boards helps directors see the full operating picture, rather than reviewing a salary decision in isolation.
A Practical Board Discussion to Start This Month
A board does not need to solve sector-wide compensation inequity in one meeting. It can begin by asking better questions:
Do we have current, relevant market information for each senior leadership role?
Does the budget reflect the true scope of leadership, finance, people and operational work required to deliver our programs?
Which roles are currently relying on overtime, unpaid extra work or a single person’s institutional knowledge?
If a major funding source were delayed or reduced, what staffing, compensation or program decisions would we need to make?
When will the board next review executive compensation and the broader workforce plan?
The answers may reveal a need for stronger revenue planning, clearer roles, a more realistic budget, or better financial reporting. The important part is to make those needs visible before the organization asks more sacrifice of the people holding it together.
Fair Compensation Is Part of Financial Sustainability
Women lead and power much of Canada’s nonprofit sector. The 2026 CharityVillage data shows that a material gender pay gap remains, including at the Chief Executive level. That should prompt an honest governance conversation.
Fair compensation is not separate from financial sustainability. It is part of what makes an organization stable, able to retain leadership, and able to deliver its mission over time.
For more than 10 years, Enkel has supported thousands of Canadian nonprofits with Bookkeeping, Payroll, accounts payable, financial controllership and CFO support. We help leadership teams and boards build the financial clarity needed to ask the right questions, understand their options and focus more of their energy on the mission.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a gender pay gap in the Canadian nonprofit sector?
Yes. The 2026 CharityVillage Canadian Nonprofit Sector Salary and Benefits Report found that men in Chief Executive roles earned approximately 20% more on average than women in the same level. At other management levels, the reported gap ranged from approximately 4% to 13%. The report notes that further analysis is needed to determine the full extent and drivers of the gap.
Why is fair compensation a board responsibility?
Boards have a governance role in approving budgets, overseeing executive compensation, and ensuring the organization can deliver its mission. A fair, documented compensation process helps the board assess leadership roles using relevant data and the organization’s financial position.
How should a nonprofit board benchmark Executive Director compensation?
Use current data that reflects the role, region, organization size, focus area and responsibilities. Consider total compensation, not base salary alone. The board should document the information reviewed, the decision made and when it will reassess the role.
Can a nonprofit afford to pay leaders fairly during funding uncertainty?
Every organization faces different constraints. A board should start with an honest view of delivery costs, available cash, restricted funding, staffing requirements, and future funding scenarios. If the current model cannot support fair compensation, the board needs to address that gap through its revenue, program, staffing or operating plan rather than treating personal sacrifice as a permanent solution.
What is the accidental CFO problem in nonprofits?
The accidental CFO problem occurs when an Executive Director or other non finance leader becomes the default owner of finance, reporting, Payroll, systems and operational decisions without sufficient support or clearly defined roles. It can create delays, weak oversight and an unsustainable workload.
How can financial operations support improve leadership capacity?
Reliable Bookkeeping, monthly reporting, payables, Payroll and Controller oversight give leadership a clearer picture of cash, spending, risks and decisions. This allows Executive Directors and boards to spend less time finding or explaining numbers and more time on mission, fundraising and strategy.





